Cape Buffalo first timer
Hi all,
I need a little advice on my upcoming Cape buffalo hunt set for August 2026. I intend to use a handgun to take this buffalo. My PH doesn’t like the idea but also hasn’t said no and says things like we will discuss later. I understand his reservation because I fudged a sable hunt with him 2 years ago using my 454. The shot hit high and we chased him for days and I ultimately put him down using my rifle.
I have put nearly 1000 rounds through my 454 over the past 2 years and am feeling confident. But I worry that 454 is not the best choice for Buffalo. I know if done right it will certainly do the job but is it the best option I have a 500 magnum 6.5” s&w and it is not enjoyable to shoot, I don’t shoot it as well as the 454 so I think I’d limit myself to 50 yards with it compared to limiting myself to 75 with the 454 (100 yards if have a perfect rest with unlimited time). Would a single shot 375 be a better option? Also it’s getting quite old everyone trying to talk me out of using a handgun on the buff. Everyone thinks it’s foolish yet bow hunters get a badge of honor for attempting a buff. How do I explain myself better to the PH and my family why using a handgun is so important to me? Every animal I’ve taken with a rifle feels lackluster and like it has an asterisk. It’s too easy and Joe blow can get off the couch having shoot zero rounds the prior year and harvest an animal.
Hitman’s success with a “handgun” is great but a 416 Taylor isn’t exactly a handgun round. So I applaud your effort to use a revolver for your hunt. However he makes an excellent point that bullet choice is paramount. As well as placement, so the stress and excitement level of being that close to your buff could easily make what would be an easy shot under normal conditions so strive for close distances and perfection on your hold, squeeze, and overall mental condition.
There is no doubt that a stout 45 colt or 454 will do a buffalo in with a proper bullet, placed properly. Several of our members have done so with revolvers. I say take the gun you shoot best, over a bigger gun. A good solid cast bullet, a Sierra SP, a solid mono bullet, would be my suggestion based on previous experiences by others. Getting your PH on your side is your biggest hurdle at this point.